- The Jurisprudence Discussion Group tests this question through the lens of Gyekye’s moderate communitarianism.
Seated around a 5th-century-BC-style amphitheater at the University of Ghana Commonwealth Hall, the second session of the Jurisprudence Discussion Group took a different spin on the centuries-old debate among Dworkin, Hart, Kelsen, and Mill on rights, autonomy, and liberty versus communitarianism. A conversation was grounded in a simple premise proposed by Professor Gyekye in his book “Tradition and Modernity: A Philosophical Reflection on the African Experience.
The premise was as follows: If extreme individualism, which favors the pursuit of liberty, autonomy, and human flourishing at all times, sits on one end of a spectrum and radical communitarianism, which requires an individual to sacrifice some part of their pursuit of self for the common good, sits on the other, what could exist in the middle? Professor Gyekye answers this by proposing the moderate communitarianism argument. He posits that in the middle of the two extremes, a convergence of both sides could coexist. This would involve pursuing individual rights while also sacrificing individual liberty for the common good. With this background, the first question to be answered was which point best described the character of Ghanaian society.
To aid the discussion, a powerful Ghanaian example advanced for the former end of the spectrum is the argument by people engaged in illegal mining and their pursuit of a living, presented as a justifiable right even in the face of harmful consequences for generations to come. On the other end, the discussion also considers the argument for reparations and the burden placed on descendants of the original actors in the slave trade. On one hand, an obligation is placed on the living to protect the unborn; on the other, a duty is placed on the dead to repair the wrongs of the past.
On consideration of the question from a legal perspective, the discussion centered on the content of the law. The Preamble of Ghana’s Constitution as a starting point revealed a multivalent approach by the drafters of the Constitution. “Posterity”, “peace with all the peoples of the world”, “accountability”, “unity”, “equality of opportunity,” on a first reading, point at a consideration of social cohesion, the well being of the larger community extending as far as outside of Ghana and a predilection for the prioritization of the group rather than the individual. At the same time, words such as “inalienable right”, “liberty”, “freedom”, and “justice” in the Preamble indicate the constitution's endorsement of an individual's ability to pursue self.
Some argued for moderate communitarianism, citing a recent social media discussion on noise-making laws and the conflict with religious freedom laws when an elderly man was captured confronting churchgoers who were engaged in a passionate session of prayer at 2 a.m. The reasoning was that nighttime was predominantly accepted in Ghanaian society as the period for rest and therefore individuals seeking rest should not have to sacrifice for the religious freedom of others. Another example centered on “black tax” , the phenomenon of paying for the care of an extended family once one reaches what the larger society perceived to be a stable earning capacity. Others argued for individualism on a class dimension, in the sense that Ghanaians chose what worked best for them if they were wealthy enough to fund their needs; however, people with less means were more likely to embrace community as a means of survival. Some spoke about the black tax and its effects.
An argument was made for Ghanaian society originally practicing radical communitarianism in pre-colonial times. Punishments such as banishment were used when a member of society was removed for harming the unit; the individual’s presence was no longer acceptable for the good of the group. However, after colonial contact, Ghanaian society has moved slowly toward a more moderate communitarian approach, attempting to balance both group needs and individual pursuits. A large majority of discussants agreed that Ghanaian society has elements of moderate communitarianism, with the scales occasionally tipping toward radical communitarianism.
On this basis, the argument for illegal mining falls flat. Our jurisprudence could not support such a blatant condemnation of the rest of society and even those yet to be born for the singular needs of one. By the same logic, the call for reparations is very much justified, given the profound duty owed to generations still suffering from the devastating and ongoing legacy of slavery.
About JDG:
The Jurisprudence Discussion Group (JDG) is an informal discussion group with members across all disciplines, professions, and backgrounds. JDG organizes quarterly meetings on jurisprudential, legal, and philosophical issues that concern Ghana, Africa, and the world.
Interested persons can send a WhatsApp message to +233556144968 to join our WhatsApp page and receive email updates on our events and meetings.
